Did SCOTUS Misquote Second Amendment History or Is the New York Times Wrong? (Ft. Jonathan Adler)
This week, in the lead-up to oral arguments in the Supreme Court's AR-15 ban case, The New York Times has accused the Court of basing its Second Amendment test on a misquote.
To discuss that accusation, we have William and Mary University Law Professor Jonathan Adler on the show. He wrote a response piece to The Times in Reason Magazine arguing that the paper has misunderstood Supreme Court citation style. And, not only that, but he says it ought to have known its claim was wrong before it published.
Adler explained the dispute is more important than a fight over proper citation might seem at first glance. The Times claimed that the late Justice Antonin Scalia misquoted a legal historian when claiming there was a historical tradition of limiting carry of "dangerous and unusual" weapons in DC v. Heller. Instead, the paper said the historian wrote "dangerous or unusual" weapons.
As Adler explained, that difference has the potential to prove decisive in the AR-15 case or any gun ban case moving forward.
But while Adler said it was true that the historian, William Blackstone, wrote "or" instead of "and," he argued Scalia's citation wasn't a misquote. Instead, he said it was clearly in line with the Supreme Court's style guide for citing to a general principle across multiple sources. That's because Scalia wasn't just citing Blackstone; he was citing a number of writers who seemingly used the two formulations interchangeably over decades of writing.
Adler said one of Scalia's former clerks told The Times it misunderstood the Court's citation rules and was wrong about what the late justice was arguing. The Times released a response to Adler's piece where it doubled down on its decision to label Scalia's citation a misquote, which he said was unacceptable.
Links:
-https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/10/us/supreme-court-guns-misquote.html?unlocked_article_code=1.QlE.J7vl.gcmsmK0uqOdx&smid=url-share
-https://reason.com/volokh/2026/11/15/is-current-second-amendment-jurisprudence-premised-upon-a-misquote/